Nalgene 32oz Wide Mouth Water Bottle vs Thule AllTrail 45L Hiking Backpack (2026)

✍️ By the 247Verdict Editorial Team📅 Updated 05 October 2026

Which is better? We compared both on score, owner ratings, pros and cons.

Nalgene 32oz Wide Mouth Water Bottle

9.0/10 Excellent

4.8★ (44,000 owners)

BPA-free Tritan, 186g, virtually indestructible. The standard lightweight hiking bottle for 30 years.

Full Review

Thule AllTrail 45L Hiking Backpack

8.9/10 Great

4.5★ (3,800 owners)

45L, ventilated back, hipbelt pockets, rain cover, accessible front opening. Scandinavian hiking pack.

Full Review

At a Glance

	Nalgene 32oz Wide Mouth Water Bottle	Thule AllTrail 45L Hiking Backpack
247Verdict Score	9.0/10	8.9/10
Owner Rating	4.8★ (44,000)	4.5★ (3,800)
Verdict	Excellent	Great

Quick Verdict

This is a genuine draw — both score within 0.15 points of each other. Nalgene 32oz Wide Mouth Water Bottle: BPA-free Tritan, 186g, virtually indestructible. The standard lightweight hiking bottle for 30 years. Thule AllTrail 45L Hiking Backpack: 45L, ventilated back, hipbelt pockets, rain cover, accessible front opening. Scandinavian hiking pack. Choose based on your specific needs. Check the current price on Amazon →

Pros & Cons Side by Side

Nalgene 32oz Wide Mouth Water Bottle

186g — less than half the weight of the Hydro Flask equivalent
BPA-free Tritan plastic is odour-free and has no taste transfer
Genuinely drop-proof — hikers report decades of use without cracking
Wide mouth fits ice, cleaning brushes and entire hands
Made in USA — Nalgene has operated from the same New York facility since 1949

No insulation — drinks warm to ambient temperature within 1-2 hours
Condensation on outside in humid conditions
Less premium feel than stainless alternatives

Thule AllTrail 45L Hiking Backpack

Ventilated back panel separates pack from spine for airflow on steep ascents
Large hipbelt pockets hold phone and snacks without removing the pack
Front U-opening allows full access to pack contents without unpacking from top
Integrated rain cover deployable without removing the pack
Thule's Scandinavian heritage in outdoor equipment design since 1942

45L is touring size — too large for day hiking, slightly too small for 5+ day expeditions
Hipbelt fit requires proper sizing — poorly fitted hipbelts are uncomfortable for long days
Premium pricing over Osprey Talon alternatives at similar capacity

FAQ

Which is better, Nalgene 32oz Wide Mouth or Thule AllTrail 45L Hiking?

Is the Nalgene 32oz Wide Mouth worth the extra cost?

Yes — Nalgene 32oz Wide Mouth Water Bottle scores higher at 9.0/10 vs 8.9/10.

Who is the Nalgene 32oz Wide Mouth best suited to?

BPA-free Tritan, 186g, virtually indestructible. The standard lightweight hiking bottle for 30 years.

Who is the Thule AllTrail 45L Hiking best suited to?

45L, ventilated back, hipbelt pockets, rain cover, accessible front opening. Scandinavian hiking pack.

What are the main downsides of each?

Nalgene 32oz Wide Mouth Water Bottle: No insulation — drinks warm to ambient temperature within 1-2 hours; Condensation on outside in humid conditions. Thule AllTrail 45L Hiking Backpack: 45L is touring size — too large for day hiking, slightly too small for 5+ day expeditions; Hipbelt fit requires proper sizing — poorly fitted hipbelts are uncomfortable for long days.

Do owner ratings agree with our verdict?

Largely, yes — Nalgene 32oz Wide Mouth Water Bottle sits at 4.8★ from 44,000 verified Amazon owners, and Thule AllTrail 45L Hiking Backpack at 4.5★ from 3,800.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links below are affiliate links.