Casper Original Foam Mattress (Double) vs Tempur Cloud Medium Mattress (Double) (2026)
Which is better? We compared both on score, owner ratings, pros and cons.
Casper Original Foam Mattress (Double)
Zoned Support, AirScape foam, 100-night, 10-year, the brand that invented DTC mattresses. Original disruptor.
Full Review
Tempur Cloud Medium Mattress (Double)
TEMPUR material, medium soft feel, 25-year warranty, SmartCool cover. The pressure relief benchmark.
Full ReviewAt a Glance
| Casper Original Foam Mattress (Double) | Tempur Cloud Medium Mattress (Double) | |
|---|---|---|
| 247Verdict Score | 8.9/10 | 9.3/10 |
| Owner Rating | 4.3★ (12,400) | 4.5★ (3,200) |
| Verdict | Great | Excellent |
| Warranty | 10 years | 25 years |
Quick Verdict
Both are strong choices, but the Tempur Cloud Medium Mattress (Double) edges ahead with a 9.3/10 vs 8.9/10. TEMPUR material, medium soft feel, 25-year warranty, SmartCool cover. The pressure relief benchmark. That said, the Casper Original Foam Mattress (Double) is worth considering if Zoned Support, AirScape foam, 100-night, 10-year, the brand that invented DTC mattresses. Original disruptor. Check the current price on Amazon →
Pros & Cons Side by Side
Casper Original Foam Mattress (Double)
- Zoned Support technology is firmer under hips, softer under shoulders — engineered for side sleeping
- AirScape foam is perforated for airflow — cooler than standard memory foam
- Casper invented the direct-to-consumer mattress category in 2014 — 10 years of market validation
- 100-night trial with free collection maintains the category standard
- 12,400 Amazon reviews at 4.3★ across years of UK ownership
- All-foam construction — no pocket spring motion isolation for couples
- Less technologically sophisticated than Eve Premium Hybrid or Simba at comparable pricing
- US brand with UK fulfilment — customer service response varies from US operations
Tempur Cloud Medium Mattress (Double)
- TEMPUR material was NASA-developed and provides the most precise body-conforming pressure relief available
- 25-year warranty is the longest of any reviewed mattress — Tempur stands behind their material for a generation
- SmartCool cover actively manages surface temperature — addresses TEMPUR material's heat retention
- Medium soft feel provides shoulder and hip relief for side sleepers
- Tempur's 30+ year clinical validation across hospitals, care homes and elite athlete facilities
- £2,000+ is a significant luxury investment — affordable alternatives achieve similar comfort for less
- TEMPUR material sleeps warmer than latex or spring alternatives despite SmartCool cover
- Extremely heavy at 55kg for a double — requires professional setup and rare repositioning
FAQ
Which is better, Casper Original Foam or Tempur Cloud Medium?
Both are strong choices, but the Tempur Cloud Medium Mattress (Double) edges ahead with a 9.3/10 vs 8.9/10. TEMPUR material, medium soft feel, 25-year warranty, SmartCool cover. The pressure relief benchmark. That said, the Casper Original Foam Mattress (Double) is worth considering if Zoned Support, AirScape foam, 100-night, 10-year, the brand that invented DTC mattresses. Original disruptor.
Is the Casper Original Foam worth the extra cost?
The Tempur Cloud Medium Mattress (Double) matches or exceeds it at a potentially lower price point.
Who is the Casper Original Foam best suited to?
Zoned Support, AirScape foam, 100-night, 10-year, the brand that invented DTC mattresses. Original disruptor.
Who is the Tempur Cloud Medium best suited to?
TEMPUR material, medium soft feel, 25-year warranty, SmartCool cover. The pressure relief benchmark.
What are the main downsides of each?
Casper Original Foam Mattress (Double): All-foam construction — no pocket spring motion isolation for couples; Less technologically sophisticated than Eve Premium Hybrid or Simba at comparable pricing. Tempur Cloud Medium Mattress (Double): £2,000+ is a significant luxury investment — affordable alternatives achieve similar comfort for less; TEMPUR material sleeps warmer than latex or spring alternatives despite SmartCool cover.
Do owner ratings agree with our verdict?
Largely, yes — Casper Original Foam Mattress (Double) sits at 4.3★ from 12,400 verified Amazon owners, and Tempur Cloud Medium Mattress (Double) at 4.5★ from 3,200.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links below are affiliate links.
Popular in Mattresses
Also Worth Considering
Vi-Spring Herald Superb Mattress (Double)
Calico pocket springs, natural wool + cotton, hand-tufted Plymouth UK, 30-year guarantee. British luxury benchmark.
Read Full Review →
Hypnos Pillow Top Wool Mattress (Double)
Hand-tufted, British wool, pocket springs, Royal Warrant. The hotel mattress in your home.
Read Full Review →
Hypnos Orthos Support Mattress (Double)
Hand-tufted, ReActivePro springs, natural fillings, Royal Warrant, UK made. The royal mattress.
Read Full Review →