Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale vs Withings Body Comp Smart Scale (2026)

✍️ By the 247Verdict Editorial Team📅 Updated 05 October 2026

Which is better? We compared both on score, owner ratings, pros and cons.

Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale

9.0/10 Excellent

4.4★ (6,200 owners)

BMI, body fat, muscle, bone mass, hydration, Garmin Connect sync, up to 16 users. Garmin's smart scale.

Full Review

Withings Body Comp Smart Scale

9.1/10 Excellent

4.5★ (4,200 owners)

Body composition, vascular age, nerve health, WiFi sync, Health Mate app. The comprehensive smart scale.

Full Review

At a Glance

	Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale	Withings Body Comp Smart Scale
247Verdict Score	9.0/10	9.1/10
Owner Rating	4.4★ (6,200)	4.5★ (4,200)
Verdict	Excellent	Excellent
Users	Up to 16	8 auto-recognised
Sync	Wi-Fi	WiFi to Health Mate

Quick Verdict

This is a genuine draw — both score within 0.15 points of each other. Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale: BMI, body fat, muscle, bone mass, hydration, Garmin Connect sync, up to 16 users. Garmin's smart scale. Withings Body Comp Smart Scale: Body composition, vascular age, nerve health, WiFi sync, Health Mate app. The comprehensive smart scale. Choose based on your specific needs. Check the current price on Amazon →

Pros & Cons Side by Side

Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale

Garmin Connect integration syncs with Garmin watch health data for unified body composition tracking
Supports 16 user profiles — the most of any reviewed smart scale
Measures weight, BMI, body fat, skeletal muscle, bone mass and body water
Colour display shows historical trends directly on the scale without needing the app
Compatible with Garmin watches for full health ecosystem integration

Premium pricing requires Garmin ecosystem to justify — standalone it trails Withings Body+ value
Colour display adds battery usage — replaces batteries more frequently than basic alternatives
16 users is more than most households need — most will use 2-4

Withings Body Comp Smart Scale

Measures body composition including muscle mass, bone mass, water and visceral fat
Vascular age and nerve health scoring provide health insights beyond basic weight
WiFi sync to Health Mate app tracks trends over months and years automatically
Recognises up to 8 users automatically by their measurement profiles
Withings' medical-grade measurement heritage in connected health devices

Premium pricing vs basic Bluetooth body composition scales
Some advanced metrics require Withings+ subscription for full analysis
Bioelectrical impedance body composition is an estimate, not clinical-grade accuracy

FAQ

Which is better, Garmin Index S2 Smart or Withings Body Comp Smart?

Is the Garmin Index S2 Smart worth the extra cost?

The Withings Body Comp Smart Scale matches or exceeds it at a potentially lower price point.

Who is the Garmin Index S2 Smart best suited to?

BMI, body fat, muscle, bone mass, hydration, Garmin Connect sync, up to 16 users. Garmin's smart scale.

Who is the Withings Body Comp Smart best suited to?

Body composition, vascular age, nerve health, WiFi sync, Health Mate app. The comprehensive smart scale.

What are the main downsides of each?

Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale: Premium pricing requires Garmin ecosystem to justify — standalone it trails Withings Body+ value; Colour display adds battery usage — replaces batteries more frequently than basic alternatives. Withings Body Comp Smart Scale: Premium pricing vs basic Bluetooth body composition scales; Some advanced metrics require Withings+ subscription for full analysis.

Do owner ratings agree with our verdict?

Largely, yes — Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale sits at 4.4★ from 6,200 verified Amazon owners, and Withings Body Comp Smart Scale at 4.5★ from 4,200.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links below are affiliate links.